Raised Bed vs. Compost: What’s the difference?
The short answer
A1 Organics Certified Compost is a great amendment: you mix it into soil to make that soil better. A1 Organics PRO4 is a soil-less growing media made to fill raised beds and containers, and it already has compost in it.
Filling a new raised bed or pot? Use A1 Organics PRO4. Refreshing a bed or improving the garden soil you already have? Use A1 Organics Certified Compost.
Side by side
| Compost | PRO4 Soil-Less Growing Media | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Stable organic matter you mix into soil | A lightweight, four-ingredient growing media |
| What’s in it | Composted tree trimmings, leaves, grass, and other clean organics | A1 Organics STA Certified Compost, Micro Fines, sphagnum peat moss, Colorado scoria lava rock |
| Main job | Improves the soil you already have | Fills a bed or pot, ready for planting |
| Fill a raised bed with it alone? | No. Too nutrient dense | Yes, that’s what it’s made for |
| Best for | Refreshing existing beds, starting in-ground gardens | New raised beds, pots and planters, greenhouses |
| A1 product | EcoPlus™ Organic Compost | PRO4 Soil-Less Growing Media |
What is compost?
A1 Organics Certified Compost is made when tiny living organisms, like bacteria and fungi, break down natural materials such as food scraps, leaves, and grass clippings with the help of oxygen. During this process, the materials heat up naturally, helping to kill harmful germs and weed seeds. Over time, these materials turn into compost, a dark, soil-like material that improves soil health, adds nutrients, holds water, and helps plants grow strong and healthy. Colorado State University Extension calls it the “gold standard” of organic soil amendments. Like any amendment, it only works when it’s mixed into the soil (CSU Extension).
Not all compost is the same. CSU notes that manure-based composts, the most common kind in Colorado, are often high in salts, while plant-based composts are usually lower. Asksk for a spec sheet or lab results before you buy (CSU Extension). A1 Organics composts are STA Certified through the US Composting Council, and EcoPlus™ is also OMRI Listed. See our test results here, or call 800.776.1644.
What is PRO4?
PRO4 Soil-Less Growing Media is our raised bed option. It’s a lightweight blend of four ingredients, each with a job:
- A1 Organics STA Certified Compost and Micro Fines bring organic matter.
- Sphagnum peat moss helps the mix hold water, improves soil structure, retards root borne diseases, and helps balance pH.
- Scoria lava rock, mined in Colorado, adds structure and aeration.
Why not fill a bed with straight compost?
More compost isn’t always better. CSU notes that root burn and plant loss are common when salty amendments are over-applied (CSU Extension). Compost does its best work blended with other materials, which is why extension guidance points to a mix rather than compost alone.
Before you fill: two Colorado tips
- Blend the bottom layer. If your fill is different from the native soil, CSU recommends mixing it into the soil under the bed so water and air can move between layers (CSU PlantTalk).
- Watch for salts. Soil amendments aren’t regulated the same way fertilizers are, and many sold in Colorado are high in salts (CSU Extension). A1 Organics tests every compost, you can obtain a STA Certification report here.
Which one do you need?
| Your project | What to use |
|---|---|
| Filling a brand-new raised bed | PRO4 |
| Pots, planters, and containers | PRO4 |
| Refreshing an existing raised bed | Compost, mixed into the top few inches |
| Starting a new in-ground garden | Compost: mixed into the top 8-12 inches of soil |
| Maintaining an existing garden | Compost: about 1/4 inch per year, mixed in |
Three cubic yards covers 1,000 square feet about one inch deep. Not sure how much to order? Our Yardage Calculator does the math.
Frequently asked questions
Can I fill a raised bed with just compost?
No. Over-applying amendments introduces too many nutrients.
Does PRO4 already have compost in it?
Yes. PRO4 contains EcoPlus™ Organic Compost and Micro Fines, along with sphagnum peat moss and scoria lava rock.
Can I use PRO4 in pots?
Yes. PRO4 is made for indoor and outdoor potting as well as raised beds, greenhouses, and nurseries.
How do I keep a raised bed healthy year to year?
Mix in a little compost each season.
Is compost the same as mulch?
No. Compost is mixed into the soil, while mulch stays on the surface to hold moisture and suppress weeds.
Is fall a good time to start a raised bed?
Yes. Prep a new bed in fall or early spring, so it’s ready to plant when the season starts.
Get your beds ready for spring
Order PRO4 or EcoPlus™ Organic Compost online and get it delivered to your home. Not sure which fits your project? Call us at 800.776.1644.
Sources